Union College and Middlebury College are both respected private liberal arts schools in the Northeastern United States. Although they share similar educational philosophies and high academic standards, each college provides a unique experience based on its history, academic programs, campus culture, and reputation. Union College, located in Schenectady, New York, stands out for its blend of engineering and liberal arts and its historical ties to fraternity life. Middlebury College, in Middlebury, Vermont, is well-known for its strong emphasis on language instruction, international studies, and environmental programs. This comparison looks at both colleges in an academic context, highlighting the strengths of Union College while examining how the two institutions stack up across important areas.
‍

Historical Background

Founding and Early Milestones: Founded in 1795, Union College was the first institution of higher learning chartered by the New York State Board of Regents. It became known as the first planned college campus in the United States. Its early embrace of modern disciplines set it apart. Notably, Union introduced a civil engineering program in 1845, the first of its kind at an American liberal arts college. This reflected an innovative spirit in blending technical and classical education. Middlebury College was established shortly after, in 1800, as the first college in Vermont. Middlebury’s history features significant milestones in education. At its second commencement in 1804, it awarded an honorary master’s degree to Lemuel Haynes, an African American clergyman. In 1823, one of its graduates, Alexander Twilight, became the first Black person in the United States to earn a bachelor’s degree. By admitting women in 1883, Middlebury was among the first New England liberal arts colleges to become coeducational. This showed its early commitment to inclusivity.

Institutional Heritage: Union College has developed a proud heritage as a multidisciplinary liberal arts institution with a technical focus. In the 19th century, it earned the nickname “Mother of Fraternities” because it was the birthplace of several early Greek-letter social fraternities in North America. This tradition shows the college’s lasting influence on American collegiate life. Middlebury, however, took a different approach with student social organizations. After many years of having fraternities, Middlebury’s administration decided to eliminate single-sex Greek organizations in 1990–91. It converted them into coeducational social houses to create a more inclusive residential environment. This change highlights Middlebury’s readiness to reform campus life to match its community values. Meanwhile, Union kept its Greek life traditions as part of campus culture, making various reforms over time to ensure balance with academic and residential life. Both colleges have produced prominent alumni and leaders. Union’s alumni include a U.S. President, Chester A. Arthur (class of 1848), and many notable figures in government, science, and the arts. Middlebury’s alumni roster is equally impressive, featuring diplomats, writers, and innovators. Its commitment to global education and civic engagement is evident in graduates who have become international leaders and changemakers. Each institution’s historical narrative shapes its modern identity—Union’s focus on educational innovation and social traditions, and Middlebury’s emphasis on inclusion and global vision.


Academic Programs and Curriculum

Curricular Structure: Union and Middlebury both offer a broad liberal arts curriculum, but they have different academic calendars and program focuses. Middlebury follows a 4-1-4 academic calendar, which includes two semesters of four courses each, plus an intensive one-course “Winter Term” each January. This J-Term lets Middlebury students concentrate on one subject or take part in internships and independent research for a month. It promotes in-depth learning and practical experience during the academic year. Union College operates on a trimester system, consisting of three 10-week terms with a longer winter break in between. Union’s calendar also provides students with flexibility. Many use the lengthy winter break for internships, research projects, or international travel, reflecting Union’s focus on practical experience in addition to classroom learning. Despite these differences, both colleges ensure that students enjoy small classes and close interaction with faculty, as indicated by their student-faculty ratio of around 9:1.

Areas of Study: Middlebury offers over 45 majors in the arts, humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences, and it is particularly known for its programs in foreign languages, international studies, and environmental science. In fact, Middlebury was the first college in the United States to create an environmental studies major in 1965, highlighting its role in sustainability education. The college is also home to prestigious summer Language Schools and the Bread Loaf School of English, further enhancing its reputation in language and literature. Students can pursue joint programs, such as 3-2 engineering agreements with other universities, but Middlebury does not grant engineering degrees. Instead, it maintains a focus on traditional liberal arts disciplines, enriched by global and environmental perspectives.

Union College stands out by combining technical and liberal arts fields within a single undergraduate college. It is one of the few liberal arts colleges that offers ABET-accredited engineering programs, including mechanical, electrical, computer, and bioengineering, alongside majors in humanities, arts, social sciences, and sciences. This blending of disciplines is a key aspect of Union’s educational philosophy. The college promotes the integration of knowledge through initiatives like its Converging Technologies program, encouraging students to connect different fields. Union’s Common Curriculum requires students to draw links between disciplines. For example, engineering majors learn about humanities and vice versa, reflecting the school’s belief that a well-rounded education creates more versatile thinkers. 

Both colleges support undergraduate research and independent study. However, Union has particularly high involvement in research and internships. About 80% of Union students engage in faculty-mentored research during their undergraduate years, and 85% complete at least one internship, showing a strong emphasis on practical learning. Middlebury students also participate in research and often complete senior theses or projects, particularly in fields like environmental studies and the sciences. The college supports these efforts with its excellent facilities, including notable science centers and library resources. 

When it comes to studying abroad, both colleges excel: over half of Middlebury's students spend at least one semester abroad through the college’s 36 international sites and partner programs, reflecting its global perspective. Union is comparable, with about 60% of its students studying abroad during their four years. They benefit from the trimester schedule and Union’s own program offerings, including rare engineering exchanges. In summary, Middlebury’s academics emphasize depth in liberal arts and global engagement, while Union provides a thorough liberal arts core enhanced by technical fields and interdisciplinary chances. Each institution appeals to different student interests. Students attracted to Middlebury often seek immersive language programs or an environmental curriculum, while those choosing Union can study classical topics and engineering at the same time.


Campus Life and Culture

Location and Setting: Middlebury and Union offer different physical and social environments, each with its distinct charm. Middlebury College sits in a rural New England town, surrounded by Vermont’s Green Mountains to the east and New York’s Adirondacks to the west. The campus covers about 350 beautiful acres and is known for its stunning landscape and outdoor activities, from skiing at the Middlebury Snow Bowl to environmental work in the local ecosystem. This peaceful setting shapes Middlebury’s culture, closely connecting it with nature, sustainability, and a tight-knit small-town community. In contrast, Union College is located in the small city of Schenectady, part of New York’s Capital Region. Union’s campus spans about 100 acres and integrates into the urban landscape, just a short walk from downtown shops and the Mohawk River. It also features its own green spaces, including the eight-acre Jackson’s Garden at the center of campus. Students at Union enjoy the perks of an accessible city, like internships in businesses or government offices and cultural events, while still living in an enclosed college environment. Union’s close distance to metropolitan areas—only a few hours’ drive from New York City, Boston, and Montreal—offers students more chances for networking and entertainment off-campus. Meanwhile, Middlebury’s relative seclusion leads to a more self-contained campus life, as students often focus on on-campus events or nearby outdoor activities. Both campuses primarily offer residential living and promote strong community ties, but the daily experience for a Middlebury student in a quiet mountain town can be quite different from that of a Union student engaging with the lively urban atmosphere of Schenectady.

Residential Life and Social Scene: Both Union and Middlebury, as liberal arts colleges, focus on building a living-learning community, but their methods differ. Middlebury guarantees housing and expects most students to live on campus all four years. It organizes undergraduates into residential Commons, blending students from all class years into smaller communities. These Commons, along with various student-run social houses and themed housing, became the foundation of Middlebury’s social life after fraternities were eliminated. This ensures that social activities are inclusive and open to all students. Middlebury’s social scene often revolves around college-sponsored events, outdoor activities, student organizations, and athletics rather than Greek life. Additionally, Middlebury promotes sustainability and global awareness in student life. It features initiatives like local food in dining halls and eco-focused clubs. Many students also participate in cultural organizations that reflect the diverse international student body, with about 12% coming from abroad, and in language programs.

At Union College, student life blends long-standing traditions, like Greek life, with newer inclusive initiatives. About one-third to one-half of eligible students, sophomores and up, join fraternities or sororities, continuing a Greek system that has existed for two centuries. Union has around 13 Greek organizations, 10 with their own residences. These groups contribute to social events, community service, and alumni networking. However, Union has structured campus life so that every student, regardless of Greek affiliation, is part of the Minerva Houses system. This includes seven faculty-led residential and social houses that involve all students, even faculty, in various intellectual and social programs. The Minerva Houses host lectures, dinners, and casual gatherings, ensuring a vibrant campus life is accessible to everyone, not just those in Greek life. All students live on campus through their senior year, fostering a cohesive community, while theme houses offer additional living options centered on shared interests. With over 130 student clubs that range from academic societies to performing arts groups and a full calendar of campus events, Union provides a lively social scene that combines tradition with inclusivity.

Athletics and Extracurriculars: Both schools emphasize athletics and wellness as part of campus culture. Middlebury is a NCAA Division III member and a founding participant in the New England Small College Athletic Conference (NESCAC). The college competes in 31 varsity sports. Despite its Division III status, Middlebury has a strong athletic record, winning multiple NCAA championships in men’s and women’s ice hockey, lacrosse, field hockey, and cross-country. About 28% of Middlebury students play a varsity sport, and many others compete on club or intramural teams, reflecting a culture where academics and athletics are both important. Outdoor recreation is especially popular; students take advantage of nearby ski slopes, hiking trails, and Middlebury’s own outdoor programs. Union College has a unique athletic profile. Most of its 26 varsity teams compete in NCAA Division III and the Liberty League, but Union’s men’s and women’s ice hockey teams compete at the Division I level. This prominent hockey program, which won a national championship for the men’s team in 2014, adds excitement to campus life. About one-third of Union students participate in intercollegiate athletics, and active intramural leagues support a culture of student engagement and school spirit. Through sports, arts (each college has strong music and theater programs), volunteer work, or student governance, undergraduates at both Middlebury and Union discover many ways to build leadership and teamwork skills outside the classroom.


Reputation, Selectivity, and Outcomes

Admissions Selectivity: Middlebury and Union both attract high-achieving students, but Middlebury’s admissions have become especially competitive. In recent years, Middlebury’s acceptance rate has stayed in the low-to-mid teens, around 13 to 15%. This reflects its status as one of the more selective liberal arts colleges in the country. The typical profile of admitted students features excellent academic credentials, such as middle 50% SAT scores around 1380 to 1530, along with a strong record of extracurricular and service involvement. While Union College also seeks well-prepared students, it has a comparatively higher acceptance rate of about 40 to 45% in recent freshman classes. Union’s selectivity is considered moderate for a top-tier liberal arts college; it offers a rigorous education to a slightly broader group of students without sacrificing academic quality. Union’s incoming classes still show strong academic metrics, with median SAT scores in the 1300s and ACT scores around 30. The college prides itself on evaluating applicants as a whole to find good fits for its interdisciplinary programs. The different admission rates partly reflect the number of applications and institutional goals: Middlebury consistently gets a large number of applicants for a class of around 600 to 700 students, while Union enrolls about 500 to 550 first-year students and has worked to maintain its enrollment numbers. From a student perspective, this means Middlebury is a reach for most students and sees itself as among the elite liberal arts colleges in terms of admissions. Union, while also well-regarded academically, can be viewed as slightly more accessible. Notably, both schools practice holistic admissions and seek diversity in their classes. Middlebury and Union each enroll students from across the United States and dozens of countries, with similar shares of international students, approximately 10 to 12% of the student body, and around a quarter of undergraduates at Union identifying as students of color. Both colleges show a strong commitment to financial aid. Middlebury is need-blind and meets full demonstrated need, supported by a substantial endowment of over $1.5 billion that allows for generous aid packages. Union, with a smaller endowment, still allocates considerable resources to aid, offering a mix of need-based grants — over 60% of Union students receive institutional scholarship assistance — and merit scholarships to attract talented students.

Rankings and Prestige: In terms of national reputation, Middlebury is widely recognized as a top liberal arts college. It often ranks among the leading liberal arts institutions in the country according to various publications and ranking agencies, usually within the top 10. Though recent fluctuations in ranking formulas have placed Middlebury around the top 15 to 20 in some listings, its overall prestige remains solid. Middlebury’s strong programs in language, international studies, and environmental fields contribute to its global academic reputation. Union College is also highly respected and typically ranks within the top 50 national liberal arts colleges. It is recognized in guides and analyses as one of the “Hidden Ivies” or “Little Ivies,” terms that emphasize excellent schools that offer Ivy League-level education on a smaller scale. Both Middlebury and Union belong to a select group of Northeastern colleges with strong outcomes, even if Middlebury has more name recognition. Importantly, alumni success and educational value aren't solely reflected in rankings. Union’s comprehensive approach produces notable outcomes; within months of graduation, Union alumni find success in various fields, including engineering, technology, finance, healthcare, law, and education. The college’s “Life After Union” data shows graduates getting positions in top firms, research labs, and service programs, or moving on to prestigious graduate schools in medicine, law, and academia. Middlebury’s outcomes are equally impressive. Its graduates frequently pursue advanced degrees, with many going on to PhDs, law school, or business school. Many also follow careers in international affairs, environmental policy, communications, and public service, areas aligned with Middlebury’s academic strengths. Both institutions maintain active alumni networks. Union’s alumni network includes leaders such as cabinet secretaries, judges, and college presidents, allowing current students to access mentorship and career opportunities. Middlebury’s alumni, spread worldwide, often connect through the college’s close-knit community for internships and career advice, particularly in global industries and organizations.

Distinctive Achievements: Each college has its unique points of pride. Middlebury’s commitment to sustainability is shown through its early initiative in environmental studies and its biomass fuel system and solar projects on campus. It reached carbon neutrality in recent years, reflecting its mission of environmental leadership. Middlebury is also known for the Middlebury Institute of International Studies at Monterey, its California graduate school, and the C.V. Starr-Middlebury Schools Abroad, which extends its global education impact. Union College’s distinct features include its architectural and historical heritage. The centerpiece of its campus, the 16-sided Nott Memorial, is a National Historic Landmark and symbolizes Union’s blend of tradition and innovation. Union’s long history with fraternities, while evolving, is a cherished tradition for many alumni. The school has balanced this by establishing the Minerva system to keep the social experience inclusive. In athletics, Union’s 2014 Division I men’s ice hockey national championship stands out as a significant achievement for a small college competing against much larger universities. Additionally, Union’s leadership in integrating STEM and liberal arts has been recognized as a national model for interdisciplinary education.


Conclusion

Union College and Middlebury College showcase the best aspects of liberal arts education while each creating a unique identity. Middlebury features a beautiful rural campus and a globally-oriented curriculum, excelling in languages and environmental sustainability while maintaining a strong academic reputation. Union offers a vibrant small-college experience in an urban environment, notable for combining engineering with the liberal arts and for traditions that connect students across generations. When comparing the two, it's clear that students at both schools enjoy small classes, dedicated teachers, numerous extracurricular activities, and alumni networks that help them after graduation. Choosing between Middlebury and Union often depends on a student's interests and preferences. A passion for international studies or a love for a peaceful mountain setting may lead someone to Middlebury. Meanwhile, a budding engineer or a student looking for a diverse urban atmosphere might find Union more appealing.

Both colleges prioritize intellectual growth, critical thinking, and community involvement, preparing graduates for meaningful careers and informed citizenship. Union College shows that a liberal arts college with a positive, interdisciplinary spirit can compete with more recognized institutions, providing an education of similar quality with its own unique benefits. Ultimately, Union and Middlebury demonstrate how traditional liberal arts schools continue to flourish in the 21st century, maintaining high academic standards and vibrant campus traditions while educating future leaders.


Sources:

1. Academics & Curriculum

• Union College Academics Overview
https://www.union.edu/academics
‍Use for: Trimester system, ABET-accredited engineering, 80% undergraduate research, 60% study abroad, 85% internship participation.
• Middlebury College Academics Overview
https://www.middlebury.edu/academics
• Use for: 4-1-4 calendar, Winter Term, environmental studies (first in U.S.), 45+ majors, language programs, global focus.

2. Historical Background & Identity

•Union College History & Heritage
https://www.union.edu/about/history
‍Use for: Founded 1795, first civil engineering program at a liberal arts college (1845), “Mother of Fraternities,” Chester A. Arthur alumni.
• Middlebury College History Overview
https://www.middlebury.edu/about/history
‍Use for: Founded 1800, first Black graduate (Alexander Twilight, 1823), coeducational by 1883, carbon neutrality, global education legacy.

3. Admissions & Selectivity

• Union College Common Data Set (2023–24)
https://www.union.edu/offices/institutional-research/common-data-set
‍Use for: Admit rate (~43%), SAT range, retention (89%), student-faculty ratio (9:1), international & domestic diversity stats.
• Middlebury College Common Data Set (2023–24)
https://www.middlebury.edu/about/information-and-statistics/common-data-set
‍Use for: Admit rate (~13–15%), SAT range (1380–1530), need-blind admissions, 10–12% international students, NESCAC identity.

4. Campus Life & Culture

• Union College Student Life Overview
https://www.union.edu/student-life
‍Use for: Minerva Houses, Greek life (25–30%), Division I hockey, urban Schenectady setting, 130+ clubs, 4-year housing guarantee.
• Middlebury College Student Life Overview
https://www.middlebury.edu/student-life
‍Use for: Residential Commons, no Greek life, Division III athletics (NESCAC), rural Vermont setting, outdoor programs, sustainability culture.

5. Career Outcomes & Alumni Success

• Union College Career Outcomes – Class of 2022
https://www.union.edu/career-center/post-grad-outcomes
‍Use for: 92% placement rate, top grad schools, alumni satisfaction >85%, notable alumni (Nobel, MacArthur, Olympic, governors).
• Middlebury College Career Outcomes – Class of 2023
https://www.middlebury.edu/career-outcomes
‍Use for: Top grad schools, Fulbright producers, global careers, diplomacy, environmental policy, strong alumni network in international affairs.

6. Global & Environmental Programs

• Middlebury College – Environmental Studies (First in U.S., 1965)
https://www.middlebury.edu/academics/es
‍Use for: First environmental studies major in U.S., carbon neutrality, Bread Loaf School of English, Monterey Institute, Schools Abroad.
• Union College – Study Abroad & Global Programs
https://www.union.edu/offices/international-programs
‍Use for: 60% study abroad participation, engineering exchanges, trimester-friendly programs, global internships, international research.