Union College and Colgate University are both well-respected liberal arts colleges in upstate New York. Each school offers strong academics and an active campus life in a close community. At first glance, they have a lot in common. They both have small undergraduate enrollments, dedicated faculty, rich histories, and good student outcomes. However, Union and Colgate also have unique traits that distinguish them. This analysis looks at both colleges side-by-side, focusing on their histories, academic programs, campus environments, student life, admissions selectivity, and other important factors. While keeping a neutral tone, the essay highlights Union College’s specific strengths and positive qualities, giving a fair view of how the two institutions compare.
‍

‍Background and Overview

‍Histories and Prestige: Union College, founded in 1795, is the second-oldest college in New York State, after Columbia University. It was one of the first non-denominational institutions in the country. Colgate University began in 1819 as the Baptist Education Society in Hamilton and later took the name of the Colgate family donors. Both schools have rich histories and are often listed among the top liberal arts colleges in the Northeast. Union proudly calls itself the “Mother of Fraternities,” as many early Greek-letter societies were established there in the 19th century. Colgate is famous for its beautiful campus, featuring iconic Georgian architecture and rolling hills, as well as the tradition surrounding the number 13, which honors its 13 founders. Both colleges have strong academic reputations and dedicated alumni networks.

Location and Setting: Union College is in Schenectady, New York, a small city in the Capital Region. Its campus fits well into the urban landscape, giving students easy access to city amenities and opportunities, like internships in technology and government offices in nearby Albany, while still offering a traditional collegiate quad and community atmosphere. Colgate University is located in Hamilton, New York, a charming rural town in central New York. Colgate’s environment is more isolated and typically “collegiate,” with the campus closely connected to the small village. The area’s natural beauty, including wooded hills and a lake, adds to Colgate’s classic campus vibe. In summary, Union combines campus life with urban access, while Colgate offers an immersive small-town college experience.

‍Quick Facts: Below is an overview of key facts for Union College and Colgate University:‍


Academic Programs and Curriculum

‍Curricular Structure: Colgate and Union both offer a broad liberal arts education, but they have different academic focuses. Colgate University’s curriculum is centered on a liberal arts core. All Colgate undergraduates complete a set of core courses across five areas of inquiry. This approach builds a shared intellectual foundation before students specialize. The Core Curriculum, a key aspect of Colgate’s academics, exposes students to various fields and ways of thinking, ranging from scientific viewpoints to global cultures. This fosters well-rounded knowledge. By the end of their sophomore year, Colgate students declare a major from over 50 fields in the arts, humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences. Popular majors at Colgate include Economics, Political Science, English, Biology, and History. The first two years emphasize breadth, followed by depth in a chosen discipline, all supported by strong writing and critical thinking requirements. Colgate does not offer undergraduate engineering or business majors, maintaining its commitment to a pure liberal arts focus. However, it has strong natural science programs and pre-professional advising for fields like law and medicine.

Union College’s curriculum also covers the full range of liberal arts and sciences, but notably integrates engineering and technical fields with the liberal arts. Union is among the few top liberal arts colleges that offer ABET-accredited engineering degrees. In fact, Union was the first liberal arts college in the United States to offer an engineering program, awarding its first engineering degree in 1845. This reflects a long-standing commitment to interdisciplinary education. Today, about 18-20% of Union students major in engineering disciplines, such as mechanical, electrical, biomedical, or computer engineering. Others pursue majors in the humanities, social sciences, sciences, or interdisciplinary fields. Union’s Common Curriculum ensures that even engineering and science majors take courses in literature, arts, and social sciences. Conversely, humanities majors receive exposure to quantitative reasoning and scientific inquiry. The academic philosophy at Union encourages crossing boundaries; interdepartmental majors and double majors are common, and programs like Neuroscience, Environmental Policy, and Digital Media combine multiple fields. In summary, Colgate leans toward a traditional liberal arts curriculum, while Union offers a hybrid model of liberal arts and STEM, appealing to students seeking a technical education within a liberal arts setting.

Academic Calendar: The two schools even structure the year differently. Union operates on a trimester schedule, with three 10-week terms: Fall, Winter, and Spring, and has an extended winter break. Students typically take three courses per term. This calendar provides flexibility for internships, research, or travel during the long winter break or over the summer. Colgate follows a traditional semester system with two semesters per year and optional short summer or winter courses. Both calendars support study abroad and internship opportunities. However, Union’s trimesters may allow students to fit in unique “mini-terms” or additional experiences during off-terms, while Colgate’s semester system aligns with many off-campus study programs.

Special Programs: Each college has notable academic offerings. Union provides several combined-degree and accelerated programs, such as the Leadership in Medicine program, which is an 8-year B.S./M.S./M.D. partnership with Albany Medical College, and a 3+3 accelerated law degree program with Albany Law School. These programs help talented students pursue professional degrees in a shorter time. Colgate does not have combined professional degree programs on campus, but many Colgate students attend top law, medical, or business schools after graduation, supported by strong advising. Colgate does offer a 3-2 engineering plan in partnership with engineering universities. A student can spend 3 years at Colgate and then 2 years at an engineering school, such as Columbia or RPI, to earn both a Colgate BA and an engineering BS. However, comparatively few students choose this path, while at Union, engineering is fully integrated into the undergraduate experience.

Faculty and Class Size: Both institutions focus on small classes and close interactions between faculty and students. Union’s student-faculty ratio is about 9:1, while Colgate’s is around 8:1. This means classes are usually small, often with fewer than 20 students, especially in advanced courses. At both colleges, professors—not teaching assistants—lead the courses, including introductory ones, and they are available to students outside of class. Individual attention, mentorship, and opportunities for undergraduate research are strong at both schools. About 75% of Union students work on research with faculty during their time there. This is a point of pride for Union, which has invested in undergraduate research programs, such as Union’s Aerogel Lab, where students have co-authored research papers and won prestigious scholarships like Fulbright and Goldwater awards. Colgate also supports undergraduate research and has a solid summer research program, though it may not have the same engineering labs that Union does. Colgate students often engage in research in natural sciences, social sciences, and humanities with faculty mentors.

Global Education: Colgate has a high rate of study abroad participation. About two-thirds of Colgate undergraduates study abroad for at least one term, which is one of the highest percentages among U.S. colleges. Many of these programs are faculty-led study groups, where a Colgate professor takes a group of students to explore a specific topic abroad, such as economics in Geneva or history in London. This shows Colgate’s focus on creating globally aware graduates. Union College also promotes international study and offers various programs abroad, including mini-terms during winter break and full-term exchanges. However, its participation rate is somewhat lower than Colgate’s. Still, many Union students gain international experience, supported by the flexibility of the trimester system.

In summary, academically, both colleges offer a strong liberal arts education. Colgate sticks to a traditional liberal arts model with a core curriculum and no in-house engineering programs. In contrast, Union offers a broader academic selection by integrating liberal arts and engineering. It promotes interdisciplinary studies and technical learning within a liberal arts context. Students interested in STEM fields or seeking an engineering degree in a small college setting may find Union particularly appealing. Those looking for a classic liberal arts college with a structured core curriculum and diverse humanities and science options may prefer Colgate.


‍Campus Life and Environment

‍Residential Life and Housing: Both Union and Colgate are residential colleges where most students live on campus, making campus life a key part of the undergraduate experience. Union College ensures housing for all students, and the majority live on campus for all four years. Union has a unique residential system called the Minerva Houses. Every student and faculty member is assigned to one of seven Minerva Houses, which function as intellectual and social communities. These houses are not linked to specific class years; instead, they mix students from all years along with faculty. Each house organizes its own events, lectures, and activities, supported by a budget and student governance. This setup is exclusive to Union and helps strengthen connections beyond regular dorm life. For example, a student might join a poetry reading, trivia night, or cooking class at their Minerva House, interacting with professors and peers from different majors. Traditional residence halls are also available at Union, especially for first-year and sophomore students. Many juniors and seniors live in on-campus apartments or theme houses. Overall, Union has a strong residential vibe. Despite its city location, it feels like a self-contained campus community. Even commuter students often stay involved on weekends due to the wide range of activities.

Colgate University also has a strong residential life system. All first-year students at Colgate are placed in a Residential Commons, which are living-learning communities that group freshmen together with faculty advisors to help them integrate socially and academically. These four Commons host orientation activities, seminars, and social events, providing new students with an immediate sense of belonging. After their first year, Colgate students can choose from various housing options, including traditional dorms, campus townhouses or apartments, and Greek chapter houses for those involved in fraternities or sororities. A significant number of sophomores, juniors, and seniors continue living on campus, and Colgate guarantees housing at least through junior year. Seniors can opt for approved off-campus housing, but many choose to stay in college residences. The Collegiate Gothic architecture of many dorms and Colgate’s beautiful campus, complete with Taylor Lake and the surrounding hills, contributes to a classic college atmosphere.

‍Social Life and Traditions: Both colleges offer a lively social scene, though they differ in some ways. Greek life exists at both Union and Colgate, but with different backgrounds. Union has a notable history with Greek life; it earned the title “Mother of Fraternities” because it was home to several fraternities in the early 1800s. Today, about 40% of Union students join a fraternity or sorority. Greek organizations at Union serve as a popular social outlet, hosting events and charitable activities. They operate alongside the Minerva Houses and various clubs, giving non-Greek students plenty of social choices. Union's administration and students have worked to balance Greek life with other community activities. For example, major campus events and themed weekends are often organized through the Minerva system or student government to include everyone. Traditions at Union include Homecoming and ReUnion weekends, the annual Steinmetz Symposium (a day when classes are canceled for students to present research and creative projects), and the Nott Memorial, which serves as a gathering point for campus events.

At Colgate, about one-third of students participate in Greek life, with several fraternities and sororities active on campus. Greek organizations at Colgate usually allow access starting in the sophomore year; first-year students do not join right away, letting them adjust to college life through the Commons first. Greek life plays a significant role in Colgate’s social scene, with fraternity parties and formals being common, but it is balanced by many other activities. Colgate has over 200 student clubs, covering everything from academic teams to outdoor adventure clubs (Colgate’s location makes hiking, skiing, and outdoor recreation popular) to performing arts groups. Notably, Colgate has traditions like Torchlight, a ceremony for graduating seniors, and celebrates the “Colgate Day” spirit every Friday the 13th (the university’s lore centers around the number 13). The Campus Commons system continues to provide social and intellectual programming after the first year, often hosting dinners, guest speakers, and intramural competitions among the Commons. At both schools, there is a strong sense of community; Union’s is strengthened by its smaller size and house system, while Colgate’s is enhanced by its isolated location that encourages students to bond closely with peers and faculty.

‍Extracurricular Opportunities: Both Union and Colgate focus on getting students involved outside the classroom. At Union, students can participate in a range of activities like performing arts, including music groups and theater productions, student government, volunteer work in Schenectady, and academic clubs. The Kenney Community Center at Union organizes many outreach projects that link students with the local community, such as tutoring programs and neighborhood improvement efforts. Union also has traditions like the annual Dutchmen Dip, where students take a winter plunge into icy water for charity. The campus frequently hosts events like the spring carnival and concert series. The Minerva Houses ensure there are always talks, cultural celebrations, or casual meet-ups taking place.

At Colgate, campus life is also vibrant. Because Colgate is in a small town, most social activities occur on campus or nearby. The university hosts events like the Spring Party Weekend, dance and a cappella performances, and a notable lineup of visiting speakers, often through the Colgate Lecture Series. There are also traditions like Songfest, a lively singing competition, and Founders’ Day celebration. Students at Colgate often enjoy outdoor activities since they are in a rural area; the university owns a cabin in the Adirondacks, and the Outdoor Education program organizes trips for kayaking, climbing, and caving. Additionally, Colgate’s residential commons and Greek life offer many social events. With its larger size, Colgate features a wide variety of clubs and intramural sports, helping most students find a community that fits their interests.

‍Athletics: Athletics play different roles at the two colleges. Colgate University competes in NCAA Division I for varsity sports and belongs to the Patriot League for most sports, as well as ECAC Hockey. This means Colgate’s sports teams, known as the Raiders, face strong competition. School spirit usually focuses on major games against Division I rivals. Colgate has a proud football history, with league championships in the past. Its men’s and women’s hockey teams attract large crowds at their games. Student-athletes make up a significant part of the student body, and even non-athletes enjoy tailgates and sporting events as social gatherings. The Division I athletic environment gives Colgate some of the feel of a larger university, including pep bands, cheerleaders, and appearances in the NCAA tournament. For example, Colgate’s men’s basketball team has participated in the NCAA tournament in recent years.

‍Union College competes in NCAA Division III for most sports as part of the Liberty League. The D-III athletic philosophy prioritizes balancing academics and athletics, and there are no athletic scholarships. About 30% of Union students are varsity athletes, and the college has great facilities, but the scale and visibility of athletics are less pronounced compared to Colgate. An interesting exception is the men’s ice hockey team, which competes in Division I (ECAC Hockey conference) and won the NCAA National Championship in 2014, making a name for Union in the hockey world. Hockey games at Union’s Messa Rink are very popular, generating a strong school spirit similar to what a major basketball or football program might create at other schools. Besides hockey, Union’s other sports, such as soccer, lacrosse, and swimming, compete against similar colleges and offer student-athletes a competitive experience, but athletics do not dominate campus social life. Generally, a student who wants big-time sports may prefer Colgate, while a student who enjoys sports but does not need a Division I environment would fit in well at Union. Both schools also provide extensive intramural and club sports for the broader student body and promote fitness and recreation. At Union, you can find both a soccer field and an intercollegiate robotics club, while at Colgate, campus life might include a morning hike up “Cardiac Hill” to class followed by an afternoon club meeting focused on environmental action.

‍Community and Culture: Culturally, Union and Colgate have the shared qualities of small liberal arts colleges. They both offer an intimate feel, rich traditions, and a focus on the undergraduate experience. However, their locations create subtle differences. Union’s placement in a small city allows students to engage with urban issues and diverse local communities. Some Union students intern with the New York State Legislature in Albany or volunteer in local schools. The campus is just a few blocks from downtown Schenectady, which has restaurants, a theater, and a growing tech sector. Some classes and clubs partner with local businesses. 

Colgate’s rural setting creates a self-contained college environment. Students often stay on campus or within walking distance for entertainment, and the school offers plenty to do. The Hamilton community and Colgate are closely linked. Students frequently visit the local farmer’s market or volunteer through Colgate’s Max Shacknai Center for Outreach. Colgate’s somewhat isolated location also fosters a strong student culture. Students tend to remain on campus during weekends and participate in events, which promotes bonding and school spirit. 

Both colleges have prioritized diversity and inclusion in recent years. Each has programs to recruit students from a wide range of backgrounds and support first-generation and international students. For example, Colgate now attracts about 70% of its students from outside the New England/Mid-Atlantic region, showing its growing geographic diversity. Union also enrolls students from around the country and the world. It has programs like the Scholars Program and Posse Scholars to bring in talented students from under-represented groups. Cultural clubs and events, like international festivals and activities from the Black Student Union, are active at both schools and enrich campus life.

In summary, campus life at Union and Colgate is fulfilling, offering a wide array of academic, social, and extracurricular opportunities in close-knit communities. Union’s location near urban areas and its innovative Minerva House system give it a distinct character that blends campus life with community engagement, and also mixes students from various years and disciplines. Colgate’s picturesque setting and its structure around commons and Greek life create a classic college atmosphere rich in tradition and strong campus pride. Neither environment is inherently better; it depends on student preference. Those seeking a more urban-connected experience and the opportunity to interact with both liberal arts and engineering students might prefer Union. In contrast, those attracted to a scenic campus in a small town with Division I sports may lean toward Colgate. Both institutions, however, offer tight-knit communities where students build lifelong friendships and enjoy a lively residential college experience.

‍
‍Admissions Selectivity and Outcomes

Selectivity and Admissions: Both Union College and Colgate University are selective schools, but Colgate has become much more competitive in admissions recently. Colgate’s acceptance rate in the latest cycle was around 17%, meaning about 1 in 6 applicants gained admission. This places Colgate among the more selective liberal arts colleges in the country. The number of applicants to Colgate has increased, and the academic qualifications of admitted students are strong, with median SAT scores often in the 1400s. In comparison, Union College’s acceptance rate has been about 40-45% in recent years. While Union is selective, it is not as competitive as Colgate. A typical admitted student at Union will have a good academic record, often ranking in the top 10-20% of their high school class, with SAT scores between 1250 and 1400 if submitted. Overall, Union provides a great chance for students seeking an excellent liberal arts education without facing the low admission odds at some peer schools. Both colleges use a holistic admissions process, looking at grades and scores—Union has been test-optional, which means applicants can choose whether or not to submit SAT or ACT scores—as well as essays, recommendations, leadership, and how well they fit with the school’s values.

It's important to note that Colgate has an early decision program that fills a large part of its class. Students who are sure Colgate is their top choice often apply ED to boost their chances. Union also offers early decision, but a smaller percentage of its class is admitted this way compared to Colgate. Neither school is easy to enter, and both attract more qualified applicants than they can accept. However, a student with a certain academic profile might find Union slightly more accessible in terms of admission chances than Colgate. This difference in selectivity doesn't directly reflect a difference in academic quality on campus. Students at Union and Colgate have similar capabilities and achievements, but Colgate has seen an increase in applications due to various factors, including ranking visibility and athletics, which has lowered its admission rate.

‍Student Body Profiles: Both Union and Colgate enroll high-achieving students who would likely succeed at either school. Colgate’s student body, with just under 3,000 undergraduates, is slightly larger than Union’s, which has about 2,200 undergraduates. However, both remain small by university standards, allowing for tight-knit communities. Colgate’s students tend to have an intellectual focus typical of liberal arts colleges, along with strong school spirit and pride in tradition. Union’s students also possess intellectual curiosity and often bring a practical or innovative aspect, likely influenced by the engineering program and the spirit of interdisciplinary study. Union has a male-to-female ratio of roughly 50:50 overall, although some engineering classes have more males. In contrast, Colgate's ratio is about 45% male and 55% female. Both institutions value diversity; typically, around 20-25% of students at each school are domestic students of color, 8-10% are international students, and students come from a variety of public and independent high schools.

‍Retention and Graduation: Both Union and Colgate have strong retention and graduation rates, showing student satisfaction and success. Colgate typically sees around 95% of freshmen returning for their sophomore year, and its four-year graduation rate hovers around 90%. Union retains about 92% of its freshmen, with a four-year graduation rate in the mid-80% range. These numbers show that most students at both colleges do well and graduate on time, far exceeding national averages. The supportive academic environment and close advising at each college assist students in overcoming challenges and staying on track.

‍Career Outcomes: Graduates of Union College and Colgate University find good jobs and placements in graduate school due to strong academics and alumni networks. Each school has a career center that offers career advice, internship programs, and recruiting opportunities. Union’s location near New York’s capital and Tech Valley provides students with internships in fields like government, engineering, and healthcare in the Capital Region. Many Union students complete internships during the long winter break or over the summer. Colgate’s alumni network is known for its loyalty and often helps current students find opportunities. For example, Colgate runs a career shadowing program and “Colgate Career Alliance,” where alumni offer mentorship. Many Colgate students secure jobs on Wall Street, in consulting, education, or tech through these alumni connections. The outcome statistics for both schools are impressive. A large majority of graduates find work or enter graduate school within months of graduation. For instance, Colgate often reports that around 95% of each class is employed or enrolled in a grad program within a year of graduating. Union’s outcomes are also strong. Many Union alumni go on to earn advanced degrees, such as Masters, PhDs, and MDs, while others enter fields ranging from finance to engineering to nonprofit work.

‍Notable Strengths and Alumni: Colgate and Union each have notable alumni, and both schools have strengths in post-graduate paths. Colgate is recognized for its strong connections to finance and business. The Colgate name carries weight on Wall Street, and many alumni work at top firms. The school also has a strong track record for placing graduates in law and medical schools. Union combines liberal arts with engineering, leading many graduates to careers in technology, engineering, and research science, along with law, medicine, and finance. Union boasts a proud history of alumni in public service and science, which includes Chester A. Arthur, a former U.S. President, as well as notable inventors and Nobel laureates. Colgate’s alumni list features political leaders, authors, and influential business figures, including former New York Governor Nelson Rockefeller and avant-garde filmmaker John Cassavetes, among others. Both colleges have impressive alumni loyalty. They enjoy high rates of alumni giving and active alumni clubs. This reflects graduates’ strong connection to their undergraduate experience and provides current students with a helpful network.

‍Graduate & Professional School: Because they are liberal arts colleges, neither Union nor Colgate offers graduate programs in most fields. Union has a couple of master’s programs, and Colgate has a small master’s in teaching program, but both focus mainly on undergraduate education. As a result, many students seek graduate education at other institutions. In this aspect, both colleges do well; their students get admitted to top graduate programs. For example, a student from Union or Colgate applying to a PhD program or medical school will have received strong preparation and personalized letters of recommendation from professors who know them well. This is a significant benefit of the small college experience. 

In summary, both Union College and Colgate University produce graduates who are well-prepared and successful. Union offers a slightly less selective admissions process, while Colgate has a more competitive one. Colgate’s national profile has risen in recent years, as seen in its low acceptance rate, but Union's quality and outcomes remain comparable to many higher-ranked liberal arts colleges. Students deciding between the two can be assured that either school will provide excellent academics and many opportunities after graduation. The choice should rely more on personal fit than on prestige since both are respected by employers and graduate schools.

‍
‍Costs and Financial Aid

‍As private institutions, both Colgate and Union have high "sticker price" costs, but they are dedicated to making education affordable for admitted students through generous financial aid. Annual tuition, fees, room, and board at each college range from $75,000 to $80,000. However, both Union and Colgate meet 100% of demonstrated financial need for admitted students. This means that if a student is accepted and can't afford the full cost, the colleges will provide a need-based aid package of grants, scholarships, work-study, and a reasonable student contribution to cover the gap between the cost and the family's ability to pay. Neither school considers financial need in the admissions decision for U.S. students; both are need-blind for domestic applicants, highlighting their commitment to access.

In recent years, Colgate University announced the "Colgate Commitment," a policy to eliminate or significantly cut loans in the aid packages for middle-income families. Under this initiative, Colgate will not include loans in the aid packages for families below certain income thresholds. For example, families with a total income up to $175,000 and typical assets are eligible for no-loan financial aid packages. This change makes Colgate more affordable for a wider range of middle-class families, as grants replace the parts of aid that would have been student loans. Colgate is also known for offering some merit-based scholarships, although most of its aid is need-based. The Colgate Commitment means that many students graduate with little to no debt, especially those from low and middle-income backgrounds.

Union College has also taken steps to support families who may not qualify for full Pell Grants but still find college costs challenging. In 2020, Union launched the "Making U Possible" grant program aimed at middle-income families. This program provides additional Union-funded grants of roughly $20,000 to $35,000 per year to students from families with incomes up to around $100,000, who qualify for some aid but might still need loans. The goal is to reduce debt by filling in the gap left by federal or state aid. Union has significantly increased its financial aid budget and offers some merit scholarships for high-achieving students. For example, the Union Scholars Program provides scholarship aid and more academic opportunities.

For students who do not qualify for need-based aid, both colleges are expensive, but many families use payment plans, outside scholarships, or parent loans if necessary. It's important to mention that both Union and Colgate have very high endowments per student, allowing them to be generous with aid. Colgate's endowment is particularly large for a liberal arts college, which supports its no-loan policy. Union’s endowment, while slightly smaller, still allows for significant aid and initiatives like funding research and internships.

Additional costs, such as study abroad, are often subsidized. At Colgate, if a student is on financial aid, that aid carries over to an approved Colgate study abroad program, so cost isn’t a barrier to off-campus study. Union also ensures that aid can be used for its terms abroad and offers special travel grants. Both schools have funds for unpaid internships or research stipends to support students during the summer.

In terms of value, both Union and Colgate work to ensure that cost does not prevent an admitted student from attending. The return on investment is strong given the outcomes; the alumni networks, career services, and academic credentials gained often lead to well-paying jobs or competitive graduate fellowships. Salaries for graduates from both schools are solid across majors. For instance, early career salaries for Union and Colgate graduates often rank in the top tier for liberal arts colleges, particularly for Union engineers and Colgate economists, although humanities majors from these schools also fare well due to their versatile skills.

In conclusion about cost, Union College and Colgate University are expensive, but both show a strong commitment to affordability through comprehensive financial aid. Colgate’s new no-loan policy and Union’s targeted grants for middle-income families emphasize that each institution aims to enroll talented students from all socio-economic backgrounds. Prospective students should use net price calculators for each school to estimate actual costs, as the differences in aid policies may make one school more affordable based on family circumstances. Overall, cost should not be the deciding factor between the two, since both institutions will work to ensure that expenses are manageable for admitted students.


‍Conclusion

‍Union College and Colgate University both offer a top-notch liberal arts education and a valuable undergraduate experience, although their approaches differ. Union College stands out with an interdisciplinary focus that combines liberal arts and engineering. It also has a unique trimester calendar and a campus culture influenced by the Minerva House system and a rich fraternity tradition. This makes it attractive for students who want a small, academically challenging college that excels in STEM fields and maintains an urban connection. In contrast, Colgate University provides the classic liberal arts college atmosphere, featuring a beautiful and cohesive campus, a strong core curriculum, Division I athletics, and longstanding traditions. These elements foster school spirit and create a loyal alumni network. Colgate’s focus on broad liberal arts and global engagement appeals to students who prefer a traditional approach to arts and sciences in a close-knit rural environment.

Academically and socially, neither school is definitively “better” than the other; it really depends on personal preference. A student interested in engineering or seeking a slightly easier admissions process may prefer Union. A student attracted to a nationally recognized liberal arts college with Division I sports may opt for Colgate. Both institutions offer small classes, close mentorship from professors, and chances for leadership and growth. Both will push students intellectually and open doors to promising careers and graduate opportunities. Importantly, graduates from Union and Colgate speak highly of their experiences and carry the benefits of a liberal arts education—critical thinking, communication, and a broad worldview—throughout their lives.

In the end, prospective students choosing between Union College and Colgate University are fortunate to have two excellent options. Visiting the campuses, if possible, can help clarify the subtle differences: the vibrant mix of technology and liberal arts energy at Union in a revitalizing small city versus Colgate’s traditional college atmosphere in the hills of central New York. Either choice guarantees a supportive community and an education that is both in-depth and wide-ranging. Union College and Colgate University each represent the best of undergraduate-focused higher education, and students at both will find encouragement to learn across disciplines, engage with their communities, and grow into thoughtful, well-rounded individuals. The points discussed—ranging from academic structure to social life—hopefully highlight what makes each college special, while affirming that both share the mission of liberal arts education: to nurture informed, adaptable, and conscientious leaders for the future.

‍
‍References

• Ivy Coach – Union College Acceptance Rate & Admission Statistics. (Ivy Coach Admissions Blog, Nov 2025). [Details Union’s recent acceptance rates and historical context; notes Union’s founding in 1795 and role as one of the first with Greek societies]

• Laura Berlinsky-Schine – The 10 Best Liberal Arts Colleges in New York. (CollegeVine Blog, 2025). [Profiles Colgate and Union among top NY liberal arts colleges; provides data on acceptance rates, enrollment, and distinctive features of each, such as Colgate’s rural setting and D1 athletics, Union’s trimester system and “Mother of Fraternities” status]

• Educational Advocates – College Road Trip: Nine Upstate New York Colleges in 5 Days. (Educational Advocates College Counseling Blog, 2022). [Contains comparative descriptions of Colgate and Union; notes Colgate’s core curriculum, popular majors, residential commons, and high study-abroad participation, and Union’s blend of liberal arts and engineering, 38% admit rate, undergrad research emphasis, Minerva Houses, and 40% Greek life]

• Paula Wheeler – Three Unique Aspects of Union College. (Galin Education Blog, Feb 16, 2023). [Highlights Union’s interdisciplinary academics (first liberal arts college with engineering), Minerva House community system, and commitment to affordability through Making U Possible program]

• Colgate University – Division I Athletics (Colgate official website, accessed 2025). [Explains Colgate’s Division I athletic programs and Patriot League affiliation, illustrating the school’s sports culture and scholar-athlete philosophy]

• Union College – Academic Programs: Interdisciplinary Approach. (Union official website, accessed 2025). [Describes Union’s curriculum combining humanities, social sciences, science, and engineering; evidence of Union’s liberal arts and STEM integration]

• Colgate University – Core Curriculum description. (Colgate course catalog/website, accessed 2025). [Outlines Colgate’s Liberal Arts Core Curriculum requirements across areas of inquiry, demonstrating the breadth of Colgate’s educational approach]

• College Essay Guy – Colleges That Offer Complete Financial Aid: Colgate. (blog.collegeessayguy.com, 2024). [Reports on Colgate’s no-loan financial aid initiative, noting: “Domestic students with family income up to $175,000 will be eligible for the Colgate Commitment… expanding Colgate’s no-loan initiative.”]

• Union College – Making U Possible financial aid program announcement. (Union News, 2020). [Details Union’s launch of additional grants for middle-income families to reduce loans, reflecting Union’s efforts to improve affordability]

• Colgate University – Residential Commons and First-Year Experience. (Colgate Student Life web pages, accessed 2025). [Describes Colgate’s residential commons system for first-year students and its role in building community and faculty engagement]

• Union College – Campus Life: Minerva Houses. (Union Student Life resources, accessed 2025). [Provides information on Union’s Minerva House system, including house events and the integration of social/academic life across class years]

• Union College Institutional Research – Post-Graduation Outcomes Report. (Union IR data, 2022). [Statistics on Union graduates’ employment and graduate school rates, demonstrating strong career outcomes and the percentage of students completing research or internships]

• Colgate University Career Services – Colgate Outcomes. (Colgate Career Services report, 2021). [Summary of Colgate graduates’ first destinations and the influence of Colgate’s alumni network and career programs on student success after graduation]